Skip to content
  • Who We Are
    • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
    • Davis Graham Women’s Network
    • Community Service
    • Davis Award
    • Environmental, Social & Governance
  • What We Do
  • Our Professionals
  • News & Events
  • Contact Us
  • Alumni
  • Careers
  • Davis Graham Legal Alert: Denver Inclusionary Housing Ordinance

    The new Denver “Expanding Housing Affordability” Ordinance amends Ch. 27 of the Denver Revised Municipal Code by: (1) revising provisions related to the linkage fee; (2) implementing incentives for developing affordable housing; and (3) adopting affordable housing requirements applicable to the creation of new dwelling units. The new policy will take effect in Denver starting July 1, 2022. In summary, the new ordinance:

    1. Requires all new residential development of 10 units or more to designate 8% to 12% of the units as affordable for a period of 99 years, regardless of whether the home is for rent or for sale. To align with state law, which requires alternatives to this requirement, the new policy includes the following options in lieu of allocating affordable housing units:
      1. An option to pay a fee-in-lieu of the affordable units. This fee ranges from $250,000 to $478,000 depending on the unit type and market area and will be calculated pursuant to the table attached hereto as Exhibit “A”.
      2. Negotiated and community-driven housing agreements in certain situations that allow for flexibility and benefit the community in alignment with city housing goals, which include the following:
        1. The dedication of land for the provision of affordable housing.
        2. An affordable housing plan to provide fewer IRUs on-site but at a greater depth of affordability.
        3. An affordable housing plan that would provide fewer IRUs on-site but the IRUs would have a greater number of bedrooms than would otherwise be required.
        4. An agreement to provide off-site IRUs concurrently with the construction of the residential development within the same statistical neighborhood or a 1/4 mile radius of the site.
    2. Increases the “linkage fee” assessed on development which does not incorporate IRUs over a period of five years. The linkage fee is imposed prior to the issuance of a building permit for any new structure or for any addition to an existing structure that increases the gross floor area of the existing structure according to the schedule attached hereto as Exhibit “A”.
    3. Offers zoning and financial incentives, such as flexible parking requirements, height incentives, and permit fee reductions, to offset the cost of building affordable units and increase the overall supply of housing.
      1. Permit Fee Reduction. An applicant will receive a building permit fee reduction of six thousand five hundred dollars ($6,500.00.00) per IRU in a typical market area and ten thousand dollars ($10,000.00) per IRU in a high market area. The building permit fee reduction shall not exceed fifty percent (50%) of the total building permit fee.
      2. Reduced minimum vehicle parking required by the Denver Zoning Code. An applicant may utilize the alternative minimum vehicle parking ratios allowed in Article 10 of the Denver Zoning Code.
      3. Commercial, sales service and repair street level exemption to linkage fee. An applicant may receive an exemption from the requirement to pay a linkage fee for the gross floor area of a primary commercial sales, services, and repair use located on the street level of a structure

    Additional resources and further details can be found on the project webpage: www.denvergov.org/affordabilityincentive.

    Nerdy Mind

    June 14, 2022
    Legal Alerts
  • Davis Graham Legal Alert: Colorado’s New Statute on Non-Competes & Confidentiality Agreements

    Colorado recently passed a new bill which is expected to be signed by Governor Polis. The bill makes significant changes to Colorado statute 8-2-113 regarding non-compete agreements. This bill has also added some additional limits on confidentiality agreements as well as non-solicitation agreements. It has provided new penalty and enforcement mechanisms. These changes are going to significantly affect Colorado law in this area.

    As you know, Colorado statute provides that non-competes are void in Colorado unless the non-compete falls into one of the statutory exemptions. Those exemptions were non-compete agreements in connection with the sale or purchase of a business; non-competition agreements for the protection of trade secrets; contractual provisions governing recovery of training or education expenses for an employee who has stayed for less than two years and covenants relating to employees who are management or executive employees.

    The new statute keeps the exemption for covenants in connection with the sale of a business, but eliminates the exemption for management and executive employees. It imposes a minimum salary threshold of $101,250.00 per year in 2022 or an annualized amount of that salary if the employee is employed for less than the full year. For employees who meet the highly compensated salary requirements, if the non-compete is for the protection of trade secrets and the covenant is no broader than reasonably necessary to protect the employer’s legitimate interest in protecting trade secrets, the covenant may be allowable.

    The new bill allows a covenant not to solicit customers for employees who earn at least 60% of the highly compensated threshold amount. That non-solicitation covenant can be no broader than necessary to protect the employer’s legitimate interest in protecting trade secrets. Currently that means that employees who earn at least $60,750.00 annually can be subject to appropriately narrow non-solicitation agreements.

    The bill does allow for the recovery of education and training expenses over the course of two years although it narrows the definition of training to exclude on the job training.

    The bill adds confidentiality agreements to the statute. Previously Colorado did not limit the use of confidentiality agreements as long as it did not attempt to protect information that was in the public. The confidentiality agreement must not prohibit disclosure of information that arises from the worker’s general training, knowledge, skill or experience, whether gained on the job or otherwise, information that is readily ascertainable to the public or information that the worker has a right to disclose as legally protected conduct.

    The bill also allows for recovery of scholarship provided to an individual working in an apprenticeship if the individual fails to comply with the conditions of the scholarship agreement.

    The bill also states that even if otherwise acceptable, the covenant will be void if the employer does not provide notice of the terms of the non-compete to a prospective worker before the worker accepts the offer of employment or to a current worker at least fourteen days before the earlier of the effective date of the covenant or the effective date of any additional compensation or change in the terms and conditions of employment that provides consideration for the covenant.

    The notice must be separate from any other covenants and in clear and conspicuous language. It must also be signed by the worker. There are additional requirements in the statute for how the notice must be given. It is important to note that the notice must contain language notifying the worker that the covenant may restrict their options for subsequent employment and specifically identifies there those restrictions are.

    Non-competes for physicians are also void, although the statute continues to allow damages to be recovered related to competition.

    This law applies to all workers who at the time of termination primarily resided or worked in Colorado. It prohibits employers from requiring the worker to adjudicate the enforceability of the covenant outside of Colorado.

    Enforcement of this statute is also expanded. Any person who uses force, threats, or other means of intimidation to prevent a worker from engaging in any lawful occupation commits a misdemeanor under this statute. An employer can be liable for actual damages and a penalty of $5,000 dollars for a worker harmed by this conduct and get injunctive relief. The statute also provides that a worker or prospective worker can recover actual damages, reasonable costs, and attorney’s fees in any action under this section.

    If an employer’s act or omission was in good faith and the employer had reasonable grounds for believing that the act or omission was not a violation of this section a court may elect to not award a penalty.

    This statute is expected to be effective August 10, 2022 and will apply to all covenants not to compete entered into or renewed on or after the effective date of this statute.

    Practice Pointers:

    • Review all non-competition agreements to determine if they comply with this statute
    • Review all non-solicitation agreements to determine if they comply with this statute
    • Review all confidentiality agreements to determine if they contain the language reflected in the statute
    • Before asking any prospective or current employees to sign a non-compete, consult with counsel.

    Before seeking to enforce any non-compete, consult with counsel.

    Nerdy Mind

    June 6, 2022
    Legal Alerts
  • Colorado’s First Clean Energy Plan – Status Report

    As this newsletter goes to print, the Colorado Public Utilities Commission will have just concluded a further evidentiary hearing in the matter of the Application of Public Service Company of Colorado for approval of its 2021 electric resource plan and clean energy plan in proceeding No. 21A-0141E. The Application was filed on March 31, 2021, and is Colorado’s first clean energy plan proceeding under Senate Bill 19-236. The Senate Bill required Public Service to include in its next electric resource plan (i.e., its 2021 plan) a clean energy plan to reduce its carbon dioxide emissions associated with electricity sales by 80% (from 2005 levels) by 2030 and to seek to achieve providing customers with energy generated from 100% clean energy resources by 2050.

    The clean energy plan was required to include a resource acquisition period extending through 2030 and to set forth a plan of actions and investments by Public Service projected to achieve compliance with the 80% requirement and 100% goal. If the clean energy plan included accelerated retirement of existing facilities, it also had to include a workforce transition plan and a community assistance plan to address the local jobs and property tax impacts of the plan.

    The application included eight portfolios of wind, solar, and dispatchable generation resources that met or exceeded the 80% requirement but with different cost impacts. The term “dispatchable” means a resource that Public Service can ramp up and down to meet operating conditions (with quick start capability of 10 minutes or less and capability to be remotely started by Public Service at any time). The dispatchable resources that are expected to be acquired are natural gas-fired electric generating resources and battery storage.

    The eight portfolios varied depending upon the actions Public Service took with regard to its Pawnee and Comanche 3 coal-fired power plants. The range of actions included converting to natural gas, early retirement in various years, or business as usual. All other existing Public Service coal-fired power plants are proposed for early retirement prior to 2030 to help achieve the greenhouse gas reduction requirement of the statute.

    Public Service’s preferred portfolio was number 7, which involved converting the Pawnee power plant to natural gas in 2027 and retiring the Comanche 3 coal power plant early (in 2039) but reducing its operations to 30% starting in 2030. As a result of these actions and Public Service’s estimate of its resulting resource needs, the preferred plan proposed the following acquisitions during the resource acquisition period:

    • 2,300 MW of wind
    • 1,800 MW of large-scale solar
    • 400 MW of battery storage
    • 1,300 MW of flexible dispatchable generation (this is 100 MW less than Public Service has today)

    All eight portfolios were based upon generic modeling results. Following the Commission’s final decision in the pending proceeding, there will be a Phase II all-source competitive solicitation which can change the type and amounts of additional resources that are added.

    Following interventions, discovery, and several rounds of filing of testimony by the parties, the application was scheduled to proceed to hearing. But Public Service and the parties were also engaged in confidential settlement negotiations to see if they could settle some of the key issues that had been identified in the proceeding. On November 24, 2021, a Joint Motion was filed requesting approval of a Non-Unanimous Partial Settlement Agreement. The Agreement addressed major issues in the proceeding including moving up the retirement date for Comanche 3 by five years (to the end of 2034), providing for a just transitions plan to address the loss of jobs and tax impacts of the early retirement on the Pueblo community in which Comanche 3 is located, and numerous other issues. The Settlement Agreement was a modification to the Application (including Public Service’s preferred portfolio 7) as to the issues addressed in the Settlement Agreement. Oppositions to the Agreement were also filed.

    An evidentiary hearing was held during the first two weeks of December and then the evidentiary record was closed. (Public comments have been filed throughout the proceeding and continued to be filed with the Commission.) The parties filed Statements of Position in January of this year and then the application was ready for Commission decision. The Commission held its first deliberations meeting on March 14, 2022, at which the Commissioners discussed but did not decide several of the major issues in the proceeding.

    Following the initial meeting, the Settling and Non-Settling Parties convened discussions regarding potential resolution of key items in a manner response to the Commission discussions on March 14, 2022. The objective of these further discussions was to resolve items and avoid the potential for a protracted reconsideration, reargument, or rehearing process that could further delay the commencement of the Phase II competitive solicitation. Avoiding such delay is critical so that bidders can qualify for available tax credits for their projects. The result of these further discussions was the filing on April 26, 2022, of an Updated Non-Unanimous Partial Settlement Agreement. This Updated Settlement Agreement was the subject of the further evidentiary hearing, which was held on May 17, 2022.

    The current proposal, as presented in the Updated Settlement Agreement, includes the following terms:

    • Retirement date for the Comanche 3 coal plant. Moves the retirement date for Comanche 3 from no later than December 31, 2034, to no later than January 1, 2031. Provides for reduction targets in operation of Comanche 3 by increasing amounts through 2029.
    • Pawnee coal plant. Provides for conversion of Pawnee to natural gas no later than January 1, 2026.
    • Other coal plants. Provides for retirement of Hayden 2 in 2027, Hayden 1 in 2028, and Craig 2 in 2028.
    • Just Transition Plan for Pueblo County – Location of Comanche 3. Proposes that:
    • Public Service will continue to make payments to Pueblo County annually from 2031 through 2040 (and allocated by the treasurer’s office accordingly) in the amount of the projected lost property tax revenues for those years, unless offset by property tax revenues from generation or transmission infrastructure sited at Comanche Station or within Pueblo County.
    • A separate Comanche 3 Just Transition Plan to be filed with the Commission no later than June 1, 2024. Through its Just Transition Plan filing for Comanche 3, the Company will conduct a standalone Just Transition Plan competitive solicitation for the replacement of the energy and capacity associated with Comanche 3. This process will occur on a standalone basis in an effort to ensure the Pueblo community and benefits to the community are the focus of the replacement portfolio, simultaneously seeking just transition benefits and the procurement of innovative technologies to help the Company progress towards a carbon-free future.
    • Public Service will own, at a minimum, $690 million in capital investment or 500 MW of accredited capacity, whichever is triggered first, for resources necessary to replace the accredited capacity of Comanche 3, provided that a showing of resource need is made in the first phase of the Comanche 3 Just Transition Plan filing and any final approved plan in the second phase must be deemed a cost-effective resource plan consistent with Rule 3601 and Rule 3617 after a full consideration of the just transition and emissions reduction benefits of the plan.
    • The Just Transition Plan solicitation will also utilize a utility ownership target of 50 percent for energy and capacity acquired that is in excess of the $690 million investment or 500 MW accredited capacity minimum, and provided that the final approved resource plan is cost-effective as set forth above.
    • Provides for a process where generic resources will fill the Company’s Phase II resource needs in 2029 and 2030 while having the 2029 and 2030 resource needs filled through the Pueblo Just Transition Plan solicitation as opposed to this 2021 ERP & CEP.
    • Next electric resource plan.
      Establishes that the Company will file its next Electric Resource Plan no later than October 31, 2026.

    Modeling results (based upon generic resources) indicate that the Updated Settlement Agreement will reduce carbon emission from 2005 levels by 85% by 2030 and by 99% by 2050.

    The modeling also shows the following resource acquisitions through 2030:

    But, as noted above, the resource needs in 2029 and 2030 will not be filled through the upcoming Phase II competitive solicitation. Generic resources will be used for 2029 and 2030 in the modeling of the Phase II bids. The 2029 and 2030 resource needs will be filled through the Pueblo Just Transition Plan competitive solicitation.

    The next step in the proceeding is for the Commission to deliberate in one or more open meetings, which can be viewed through the Commission’s webcast. Go to: https://puc.colorado.gov/webcasts The Commission will be deliberating regarding the proposed Modified Settlement Agreement and all issues raised in the proceeding that were not included in the Modified Settlement Agreement. (A list of the unsettled issue was filed with the Commission following the May 17, 2022, hearing.) Once the Commission has deliberated on and decided all issues, an initial written decision will be written and signed by the Commissioners. Parties in the proceeding will then have 20 days after the mailing date of the Commission decision (as printed on page one of the Decision) within which to request rehearing, reargument, or reconsideration (“RRR”). If no requests for RRR are filed within the 20-day time period, then the Commission’s decision becomes the final decision of the Commission. If the Commission does not act upon an application for RRR within 30 days of its filing, the application is denied and the Commission’s initial decision is final. If one or more requests for RRR are filed and the Commission elects to act on them, then the initial decision, as modified by the Commission’s decision on RRR, becomes the final decision of the Commission. See Commission Rule 1506. A Final Commission Decision may be appealed to state district court. § 40-6-115, C.R.S.

    Once there is a final Commission Decision, the next step will be for Public Service to make any modifications required by the Commission’s Decision and get set up to conduct an all source competitive solicitation to fill the resource need approved in the Commission’s Decision. Once the request for proposals (“RFP”) is issued, bidders will have 90 days within which to submit their bids in accordance with the detailed instructions in the RFP bid package.

    A Commission initial Decision is expected in early summer.

    Nerdy Mind

    May 26, 2022
    Legal Alerts
  • Army Corps Reissues and Revises Nationwide Permits under CWA Section 404 Program and NWP 12 Again Under Attack

    On December 27, 2021, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (“Corps”) issued a final rule regarding its Nationwide Permits (“NWPs”) for dredge and fill activities (“December 2021 Rule”). See 86 Fed. Reg. 73522 (Dec. 27, 2021). The December 2021 Rule reissued 40 NWPs and issued one new NWP. The Rule also retained consequential changes made to 16 other NWPs in January 2021 and incorporated some of those changes into the newly reissued permits. Most significantly, the December 2021 Rule retained and extended to all NWPs a stringent new mitigation condition adopted in January 2021. The new and revised NWPs took effect on February 25, 2022.

    In addition, as of late May 2022, a lawsuit is pending in Montana challenging and attempting to rescind NWP 12 for oil and gas pipelines. The Corps has also undertaken a formal review of that NWP, after seeking public comment about whether NWP 12 should be made more limited or restrictive. Entities seeking to use these revised or challenged NWPs should carefully review the pertinent revisions and stay apprised of the pending challenges and ongoing agency review of NWP 12.

    Background on the Corps’ Nationwide Permit Program

    The Corps regulates dredge and fill activities (e.g., stream crossings and wetland fills) under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act (“CWA”), 33 U.S.C. § 1344, and Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act, 33 U.S.C. § 403. In lieu of requiring individual permits for every regulated activity, the CWA authorizes the Corps to issue “general” permits, including NWPs, for categories of activities that “are similar in nature, will cause only minimal adverse environmental effects when performed separately, and will have only minimal cumulative adverse effect on the environment.” 33 U.S.C. § 1344(e)(1). Project proponents commonly rely on NWPs for earth-moving activities associated with real estate development, mining, oil and gas activities, water, transportation, and energy facilities, and related maintenance and repair operations. The Corps’ website has a useful summary of the 57 current NWPs, including changes from the last two rulemakings.

    Many renewable energy facilities and other sustainability projects benefit from the Corps’ NWP Program. For example, the Corps has issued NWPs for land-based renewable energy generation facilities (NWP 51) and water-based renewable energy generation pilot projects, like offshore wind farms (NWP 52). As discussed below, the Corps recently issued a new NWP for water reclamation and reuse facilities (NWP 59), such as wastewater treatment plants that produce treated effluent for reuse applications like irrigation. And, of course, all these types of projects also benefit from more general NWPs, like NWP 3 (for maintenance activities), NWP 57 (for electric utility and telecom lines), and NWP 58 (for other types of non-oil and gas utility lines).

    NWPs greatly reduce—but do not eliminate—the complexities of dredge and fill permitting. Some NWPs require project proponents to provide the Corps with pre-construction notification (“PCN”), which allows the Corps to evaluate NWP-eligible projects on a case-by-case basis. PCN requirements vary by NWP and project type. For example, under NWP 51, proponents of land-based renewable energy generation facilities must submit a PCN if the proposed activity will result in the loss of more than 0.10 acres of waters in the United States. In contrast, under NWP 44, all mining activities are subject to PCN.

    The Corps imposes terms and conditions for projects through conditions in each NWP and in the Nationwide Permit General Conditions. For example, under General Condition 23 as revised in 2021 (see below), the Corps requires compensatory mitigation at a minimum one-to-one ratio for projects that require PCN and will result in the loss of more than 0.10 acres of wetland or more than 0.03 acres of stream bed. Each District Office may impose additional or amended conditions for the use of NWPs within its district, including project-specific conditions and region-wide PCN requirements that do not appear on the face of the NWPs. See 33 C.F.R. § 330.4(e)(1), (2). Each state also may impose additional restrictions or conditions on certain NWPs (when used within such state) through CWA Section 401 certification of the new or newly reissued NWPs. Section 401 certification nominally must occur within one year of issuance of the NWPs.

    The Corps Addressed 16 NWPs in a Final Rule Issued in Early 2021

    Under the CWA, the Corps may issue an NWP or other regional or statewide general permit for only five years, requiring periodic reissuance. Prior to December 2021, the Corps last issued new and revised NWPs just 11 months earlier, in January 2021. See 86 Fed. Reg. 2744 (January 13, 2021) (“January 2021 Rule”). However, the January 2021 Rule only applied to 16 NWPs. This resulted in two groups of NWPs subject to two different expiration dates—those issued or reissued in January 2021 (set to expire on March 14, 2026) and those last issued or revised in January 2017 (set to expire on March 18, 2022), see 82 Fed. Reg. 1860.

    The January 2021 Rule complicated the NWP program in two other ways. First, the Corps issued revised NWP General Conditions that applied only to the 16 NWPs addressed by that Rule. Notably, the Corps set a 0.03-acre threshold for the amount of stream-bed loss that triggers required compensatory mitigation and made that mitigation requirement applicable to all 16 NWPs if and when they require PCN. Id. at 2871.

    Second, due to long-pending controversies over the use of NWP 12 for extensive oil and gas pipelines, the Rule separated linear transmission projects into three categories subject to separate NWPs. NWP 12—which previously covered linear transmission projects generally—was revised to apply only to construction, maintenance, repair, and removal of oil and natural gas pipelines and associated activities. Id. at 2769. Two new NWPs were issued to cover electric and telecommunication projects (NWP 57) and water and any other utility line projects (NWP 58).

    The Corps Declined to Revisit the January 2021 Rule in Its Recent Final Rule

    The Corps issued another final rule in December 2021. Given that the January 2021 Rule was issued in the last days of the Trump Administration, some commentators expected the Corps to walk back changes to the NWPs, including the more lenient standards imposed on oil and gas pipeline projects under NWP 12. However, the Corps declined to revisit the NWPs and conditions issued or revised in January 2021, instead opting to restore some consistency across the NWP program. See 86 Fed. Reg. 73522, 73525.

    Five
    important takeaways
    from the December 2021 Rule are as follows:

    1. The General Conditions issued or revised in January 2021 now apply to all NWPs. See 86 Fed. Reg. 73522, 73525. Most importantly, all 57 NWPs are now subject to a uniform General Condition 23, requiring at least one-to-one compensatory mitigation for any project that requires PCN and will cause the loss of more than 0.03 acres of stream bed. This is an extremely low threshold. Because streams are considered “difficult-to-replace resources,” the Corps encourages permittees to implement stream rehabilitation, enhancement, or preservation to accomplish compensatory mitigation; however, permittees also may accomplish mitigation through restoration or enhancement of riparian areas. See 86 Fed. Reg. 2744, 2871; see also 33 C.F.R. § 332.3(e)(3). Potential NWP permittees should carefully consider whether their project will trigger this mitigation requirement and, if so, determine in advance how, where, and when the requirement can be satisfied. This determination may call for pre-construction conferral with the Corps.
    2. The Corps did not reconsolidate NWPs 12, 57, and 58, and will continue to authorize dredge and fill activities associated with eligible oil and gas pipeline projects only under NWP 12 or individual Section 404 permits. Proponents of other linear transmission projects seeking to use an NWP must still seek authorization under the two distinct permits issued early last year, NWP 57 (electric utility line and telecommunication activities) and NWP 58 (utility line activities for water and other substances).
    3. The Corps reissued 40 NWPs but only amended the text of a few of them. The textual changes made in the December 2021 Rule were minor. For example, the Corps added “driveways” to the list of linear transportation projects covered by NWP 14. 86 Fed. Reg. 73522, 72535, 73574. The January 2021 Rule, on the other hand, implemented more consequential changes to the NWPs, such as eliminating provisions that used to disqualify projects from NWP authorization if they would cause the loss of more than 300 linear feet of stream bed. See 86 Fed. Reg. 2744, 2785.
    4. The Corps issued one new permit, NWP 59, which authorizes discharges of dredged or fill material from the construction, expansion, and maintenance of water reclamation and reuse facilities. See 86 Fed. Reg. 73522, 73558. The Corps recognized the importance of such facilities for climate change adaptation, including both potable and non-potable reuse applications.
    5. All existing NWPs now expire on the same date, March 14, 2026.

    To some extent, the December 2021 Rule reduces the complexity and uncertainty injected into the NWP program by the January 2021 Rule—the regulated community can again look to a single set of NWPs, with uniform General Conditions and expiration dates. That said, the December 2021 Rule could greatly expand the number of projects that need to conduct compensatory mitigation by extending the expanded General Condition 23 to all 57 NWPs.

    Prospective NWP permittees also should be on the lookout for any regional NWP conditions added or amended by the Corps’ District Offices, as well as any state-specific conditions added by states through their CWA Section 401 certification of the NWPs. Permittees should pay special attention to any new PCN requirements added by those supplemental conditions, which could trigger General Condition 23’s stringent mitigation requirement for NWPs that do not on their face require PCN.

    The Corps’ December 2021 Rule Is Not the Final Word on NWP 12

    Although the Corps declined to reconsolidate or otherwise revise NWPs 12, 57, and 58, controversy remains over the provisions of NWP 12. In May 2021, environmental organizations, including the Center for Biological Diversity and Sierra Club, sued the Corps in the District of Montana. See Center for Biological Diversity, et al. v. Spellmon, et al., No. 4:21-cv-47-BMM (D. Mont. May 3, 2021). The plaintiffs contend that reissuance of NWP 12 violated the Endangered Species Act, National Environmental Policy Act, and Clean Water Act, and they ask the court to vacate the permit. As of late May 2022, cross-motions for summary judgment are pending before Chief Judge Brian Morris.

    Spellmon illustrates some of the tensions inherent in the clean energy transition. The plaintiffs take issue with the streamlined permitting afforded to oil and gas pipeline projects under NWP 12, but their arguments are not entirely unique to oil and gas issues. In an amicus brief filed on April 1, 2022, the Edison Electric Institute argued that the plaintiffs’ claims under the ESA, NEPA, and CWA threaten to undermine the entire NWP Program—and hence, the streamlined permitting process upon which renewable energy and other sustainability projects have come to rely. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce raised a similar concern in its amicus brief.

    Amidst the flurry of briefing in Spellmon, the Corps published a notice of its intent to conduct a formal review of NWP 12. See 87 Fed. Reg. 17281 (Mar. 28, 2022). In the Corps’ view, “[p]revious uses of NWP 12 have raised concerns identified in Executive Order 13990, such as environmental justice, climate change impacts, drinking water impacts, and notice to impacted communities.” Id. at 17282. As part of its review, the Corps held public meetings throughout May 2022 and solicited public comment on a variety of topics, including whether further limits on NWP 12 or changes to the NWP General Conditions would be prudent. Id. at 17283. The Corps’ review will likely track President Biden’s emphasis on progressive environmental policies like environmental justice and climate change mitigation. However, further changes to the NWP General Conditions could have unintended impacts on sustainability projects, which already face more onerous mitigation requirements following the December 2021 Rule.

    Entities seeking to use any NWPs should carefully review and comply with the pertinent changes to those NWPs and should also closely follow the pending challenges and ongoing agency review of NWP 12, which may very well have ramifications for the entire NWP Program.

    Nerdy Mind

    May 24, 2022
    Legal Alerts
  • Colorado’s Energy-Related Bills in the 2022 Legislative Session

    The Colorado General Assembly wrapped up its 2022 legislative session on May 11, 2022. In our February newsletter, we provided an overview of energy-related bills as of February 8, 2022. At that time, only a handful of energy-related bills had been proposed. But by the end of the session, the legislature considered almost 20 bills related to energy, environmental protection, and air quality. This update highlights some of the final bills that were passed and some that were not.

    Energy-Related Bills That Passed

    Many of the bills passed this session are aimed at furthering clean energy development in Colorado. Here are some of the highlights:

    • House Bill 22-1381, Colorado Energy Office Geothermal Energy Grant Program: This bill creates a geothermal energy grant program to facilitate the development of geothermal heating systems and geothermal electricity generation.
    • Senate Bill 22-118, Encourage Geothermal Energy Use: This bipartisan bill seeks to encourage the use of geothermal energy by providing regulatory treatment similar to that afforded solar energy. Among other provisions, the bill requires the Colorado energy office to develop basic consumer education and guidance about leased or purchased geothermal installation, in consultation with industries that offer these options to consumers.
    • Senate Bill 22-110, Equip Wind Turbine Aircraft Detection Lighting System: This bill requires an owner or operator of certain wind-powered energy generation facilities to equip them with an aircraft detection lighting system.
    • House Bill 22-1362, Building Greenhouse Gas Emissions: This bill updates the state’s minimum energy code requirements. Among other things, the bill requires the creation of the building electrification for public buildings grant program, creating the high-efficiency electric heating and appliances grant program, and establishing the clean air building investments fund.
    • House Bill 22-1355, Producer Responsibility Program For Recycling: This bill requires companies that sell consumer-facing packaging to join a producer responsibility organization, which in turn would charge fees to fund a statewide recycling system.

    Energy-Related Bills That Failed

    One of the more prominent energy-related bills to fail in the 2022 legislative session was Senate Bill 22-138, titled Reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions In Colorado. This bill concerned measures to promote reductions in greenhouse gas emissions by, among other things, incentivizing people to buy electric lawn equipment. It also included measures directed at streamlining carbon capture and sequestration projects in Colorado, including giving the Colorado Oil and Gas Conservation Commission authority to issue and enforce Class VI injection wells used for sequestration of greenhouse gases.

    In addition, two of the bills mentioned in our February 2022 newsletter were ultimately rejected by the legislature. Senate Bill 22-073, titled Alternative Energy Sources, would have directed the state to investigate the feasibility of using small modular nuclear reactors as a carbon-free energy source for Colorado. That bill was sent to the State, Veterans, and Military Affairs Committee, where it ultimately died. House Bill 1140, titled Green Hydrogen To Meet Pollution Reduction Goals, would have directed the state to recognize green hydrogen as a renewable energy source that certain retail electric service providers could use to meet statewide greenhouse gas pollution reduction goals. That bill was ultimately killed in the House Energy and Environment Committee.

    What Should We Expect from the 2023 Legislative Session?

    It’s too soon to say. But at the end of this session, none of the bills proposed addressed pore space ownership. As we noted in our February 2022 newsletter, ownership of the pore space remains unresolved in Colorado, and obtaining certainty about who owns the pore space is critical to encouraging investment in carbon capture, use, and sequestration projects. Given this uncertainty, we might expect to see the Colorado legislature pick up that issue during the 2023 legislative session.

    Nerdy Mind

    May 23, 2022
    Legal Alerts
  • The Superfund Program Goes Green – Part II

    As the Biden Administration continues to prioritize climate change mitigation, EPA has renewed its focus on more environmentally friendly remedies at Superfund and other cleanup sites. In Part I of this series, we discussed EPA’s “Superfund Climate Resilience” initiative, aimed at evaluating remedy protectiveness in the face of extreme weather events. In this second installment, we discuss a likely re-boot of EPA’s “Greener Cleanups” initiative, which currently is focused on reducing the environmental footprint of Superfund cleanups by factoring in the significant resource consumption associated with heavily engineered remedies.

    The Greener Cleanups initiative is built around the concept of “Green Remediation” – the practice of “considering all environmental effects of remedy implementation and incorporating options to minimize the environmental footprint of cleanup actions.” EPA has identified five core objectives for Greener Cleanups:

    1. Minimize total energy use and maximize use of renewable energy
    2. Minimize air pollutants and greenhouse gas emissions
    3. Minimize water use and impacts to water resources
    4. Reduce, reuse, and recycle material and waste
    5. Protect land and ecosystems

    See Principles for Greener Cleanups, U.S. EPA, Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response (Aug. 27, 2009), at 4 (“2009 Principles”).

    To achieve these objectives, parties are encouraged to evaluate Best Management Practices (BMPs) that may be appropriate for a given site. EPA publishes fact sheets discussing BMPs for various cleanup phases and scenarios, including reliance on renewable energies for in situ soil and groundwater remediation. The American Society for Testing and Materials also maintains a Standard Guide for Greener Cleanups, ASTM E2893-16e1, which provides another tool for designing and implementing Green Remediation strategies. And, to assist with analysis of complex sites, EPA has published a detailed technical support document. See Methodology for Understanding and Reducing a Project’s Environmental Footprint, U.S. EPA, Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response, EPA 542-R-12-002 (Feb. 2012). The Methodology identifies key metrics for complex environmental footprint analysis (e.g., tons of carbon dioxide equivalent emitted) and explains how to calculate these metrics. Id.

    Thus far, EPA’s Greener Cleanups initiative is focused narrowly on reducing the environmental footprint associated with remedy implementation. The Agency has been quite clear that it does not intend to add any consideration of the environmental footprint of a site’s future use to the CERCLA decision-making process. See, e.g., 2009 Principles
    at 2 (“[G]reener cleanup assessments generally are not designed to provide information on the environmental impacts associated with future uses of property.”). The Agency also has said that the Greener Cleanups initiative is not intended to amend the National Contingency Plan (NCP) in any way. See Memorandum: Consideration of Greener Cleanup Activities in the Superfund Cleanup Process, from James Woolford, Director of Office of Superfund Remediation and Technology Innovation, to Regional Superfund National Program Managers (Aug. 2, 2016), at 2. Yet, at the same time, EPA has acknowledged that the environmental footprint associated with remedy implementation is relevant under the NCP in evaluating the short-term effectiveness of remedial alternatives. See Att. 2 to 2009 Principles, at 4.

    Given the Biden Administration’s focus on climate policy, we anticipate more clarity and a more comprehensive approach going forward. The President’s Executive Order 14008 on climate change prioritizes “build[ing] resilience, both at home and abroad, against the impacts of climate change.” The Administration is also focused on promoting the clean energy sector. See Executive Order 14057. In addition, the Administration’s Infrastructure Bill earmarks significant funding specifically for cleanup-related initiatives, including $3.5 billion for Superfund cleanups and $1.5 billion for community-led brownfields revitalization projects.

    Given these policies and the increasing focus on climate change mitigation and adaptation at all levels of government and in the private sector, sustainability considerations are going to play a role in all aspects of remedy-related decision making – whether EPA takes formal action or not. Many communities where these sites are located are going to demand nothing less, and mobilized communities can leverage the NCP’s “community acceptance” criterion to impact cleanup-related decision-making.

    The repurposing of cleanup sites for renewable energy production is the current exemplar of a more holistic approach to greener cleanups. In October 2021, EPA reported an 85% increase in installed solar capacity at landfill sites in the last five years, as well as implementation of renewable energy projects at 74 Superfund sites to date. See Re-Powering America’s Land Initiative: Project Tracking Matrix, U.S. EPA, Office of Land and Emergency Management (Oct. 2021), at 4, 8. Ultimately, Superfund remedies should capitalize on the synergy between sustainable cleanup strategies and intended final land uses. Final uses inform cleanup objectives, and hence, the required intensity and footprint.

    Of course, different sites will present differing opportunities and challenges. For some sites, remedy resilience and greener cleanup objectives will be complementary – consider a solar installation at a rural landfill site. At other sites, remedy selection may have to prioritize resilience over environmental footprint. For example, a water treatment plant at an isolated, high-elevation, seasonally inaccessible mine site needs a reliable source of power and facilities resilient to major weather systems and avalanches. Wind or solar power in this circumstance may not be an option.

    This series, thus far, has focused on these two aspects of sustainability – remedy resilience and environmental footprint. In Part III, we will focus on the third leg of the sustainability tripod: environmental justice considerations in remedy selection and five-year reviews. Aligning all three factors to support good decision-making in disadvantaged communities – whether isolated rural towns or congested urban centers – is complicated. One thing is clear, though, and that is the need to move beyond over-engineered remedies with unachievable cleanup objectives that, at enormous expense, fail to protect, support, or enhance the communities where these sites are located.

    Nerdy Mind

    February 11, 2022
    Articles, Legal Alerts
  • FWS Increases Take Limits for Eagle Permits

    On February 1, 2022, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) published a notice
    in the Federal Register announcing that FWS has increased take limits for permits to take bald eagles. These take limits establish a ceiling on the aggregate amount of incidental take of bald eagles that FWS can authorize through permits in its Eagle Management Units (EMUs). In the notice, FWS announced its decision to increase take limits in four of its six EMUs following a periodic review of biological data and reassessment of take limits. FWS increased the collective take limits across all four EMUs from 3,731 to 15,832.

    In 2016, FWS had revised its regulations
    governing permitting of eagle incidental take and, at the same time, completed a biological status assessment for both bald and golden eagles and a Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement (PEIS). Through this effort, the FWS established six EMUs: the Atlantic Flyway, Mississippi Flyway, Central Flyway, Pacific Flyway north of 40° north latitude, Pacific Flyway south of 40° north latitude, and Alaska. FWS then set take limits in each EMU. FWS based these take limits on appropriate take rates and the 20th quantile of the EMU population size estimate, both of which FWS identified through its 2016 rulemaking and review. FWS also committed to update population size estimates and update take rates and limits every six years.

    Because six years had passed since FWS’s 2016 biological status assessment and PEIS, FWS reviewed biological data and reassessed the take limits. The updated eagle take limits resulted from increased population estimates and an increased take rate. In 2016, FWS had relied on 2009 data to estimate that the bald eagle population in the U.S. was 143,000. In 2019, however, FWS estimated that the bald eagle populations in four EMUs increased to 316,708. Similarly, in 2016, FWS had determined that a take rate of 0.06 was consistent with its management objective for bald eagles. In 2022, FWS updated its estimate of the appropriate take rate to 0.09.

    These updates resulted in notable increases to the bald eagle take limits:

    Bald Eagle Management Unit

    2009 Population Size (20th quantile)

    2009 Take Limit

    2019 Population Size (20th quantile)

    New Take Limits

    Atlantic Flyway

    20,387

    1,223

    72,990

    4,223

    Mississippi Flyway

    27,334

    1,640

    137,917

    7,986

    Central Flyway

    1,163

    70

    26,253

    1,521

    Pacific Flyway North

    13,296

    798

    36,302

    2,102

    Total

    62,180

    3,731

    273,327

    15,832

    FWS observed that, in 2020, the actual permitted bald eagle take was 490 and stated that “the higher updated take limits will not in themselves lead to increased take.”

    FWS explained that it did not modify take limits for the Alaska and Pacific Flyway South bald eagle EMUs because FWS did not complete surveys in these EMUs.

    FWS’s notice follows FWS’s publication of an advance notice of proposed rulemaking seeking comment on potential approaches for further expediting and simplifying the permit process authorizing incidental take of eagles. FWS anticipates publishing a proposed rule later this year.

    Nerdy Mind

    February 8, 2022
    Articles, Legal Alerts
  • Colorado’s Energy-Related Bills in the 2022 Legislative Session

    The Colorado General Assembly began its 2022 lawmaking term on January 12, 2022. The legislature, which consists of 65 representatives and 35 senators, will work through May 11 to address issues ranging from school funding to tax policy to alternative energy sources. This update provides an overview of the proposed bills that relate to clean energy and energy resiliency, what’s missing, and how you can stay up to date on the 2022 legislative session.

    Energy Legislation to Watch in 2022

    SB22-073, Alternative Energy Sources

    This bill, introduced by Senator Bob Rankin and Representative Hugh McKean, proposes a study investigating small modular nuclear reactors as a carbon-free energy source for Colorado. It also proposes expanding the megawatt threshold for hydroelectricity, so that a pumped hydroelectricity generation unit with a nameplate capacity of 400 megawatts or less constitutes “recycled energy.” “Recycled energy,” which uses heat leftover from industrial processed to generate electricity with no additional fuel or emissions, constitutes an “eligible energy resource” under Colorado. Colorado’s Renewable Energy Standard requires qualifying retail utilities to generate a minimum amount of electricity from “eligible energy resources.” C.R.S. § 40-2-124. This proposed bill would expand the definition of “eligible energy resources,” and could provide more flexibility to utilities in meeting their requirements under the Renewable Energy Standard. You can find the full text of the bill here and track the bill here.

    HB22-1013, Microgrids For Community Resilience Grant Program

    This bipartisan bill concerns the creation of a grant program to finance the development of microgrids in rural communities that are at significant risk of severe weather or natural disaster events. As noted in the Bill Summary, “[t]he microgrids, which can be connected to or be disconnected from, and work independent of, the utility’s electric grid, can increase an eligible rural community’s resilience regarding any interruptions to the electric grid, such as those caused by severe weather or natural disaster events.” You can find the full text of the bill here and track the bill here.

    SB22-118, Encourage Geothermal Energy Use

    This bipartisan bill seeks to encourage the use of geothermal energy by providing similar treatment to solar energy. Among other provisions, the bill will require the Colorado energy office to develop basic consumer education and guidance about leased or purchased geothermal installation, in consultation with industries that offer these options to consumers. You can find the full text of the bill here
    and track the bill here.

    SB22-110, Equip Wind Turbine Aircraft Detection Lighting System

    This bill requires an owner or operator of certain wind-powered energy generation facilities to equip the facility with an aircraft detection lighting system. You can find the full text of the bill here and track the bill here.

    HB22-1140, Green Hydrogen To Meet Pollution Reduction Goals

    This bill recognizes green hydrogen as a renewable energy source that certain retail electric service providers may use to meet statewide greenhouse gas pollution reduction goals. In addition, the bill requires the governor to update the Colorado greenhouse gas pollution reduction roadmap to expressly recognize green hydrogen as a renewable energy resource. You can find the full text of the bill here and track the bill here.

    What’s Missing?

    None of the currently proposed bills address pore space ownership. As we wrote about in our July 2021 newsletter, carbon capture, use, and sequestration (“CCUS”) is increasingly attracting interest as a mechanism to reduce carbon emissions. To sequester carbon, a developer must inject the carbon underground through injection wells into the pore space. The pore space is comprised of the tiny voids in subsurface rock that are unoccupied by solid material, which could be used for the permanent sequestration of carbon. Some states, including Wyoming and North Dakota, have enacted statutes defining the “pore space” and who owns it. But under Colorado law, ownership of the pore space remains unclear. That uncertainty presents an obstacle to further investment and development in these projects.

    Despite this uncertainty, at the time of writing, legislation addressing pore space ownership has not yet been proposed for the 2022 legislative session.

    How to Stay Up-To-Date?

    If you’re interested in tracking a particular bill, the website for each bill includes information about when and where it is scheduled for debate. You can also track particular issues, like energy and environment, by following specific committees that focus on that work. Here is a link to the committees in both the House and Senate. You can tune into live recordings of committee hearings by checking out this link.

    Nerdy Mind

    February 8, 2022
    Articles, Legal Alerts
  • Five Federal Agencies Lead by the Department of Interior Aim to Prioritize & Expedite Permitting for Renewable Projects

    On January 6, 2022, a Memorandum of Understating (MOU) between the Department of Interior (DOI) and the Department of Agriculture (USDA), the Department of Defense (DOD), the Department of Energy (DOE), and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) announced the agencies’ intent to improve public land renewable energy project permit coordination. The Energy Act of 2020[1] authorized this initiative with the goal of improving interagency permitting coordination for the expedited processing of wind, solar, and geothermal applications on federal lands. Pursuant to the Energy Act of 2020, the Secretary of Interior established a National Renewable Energy Coordination Office (National RECO) within the Bureau of Land Management’s (BLM) Headquarters and five RECOs in the western states (BLM RECOs) with the responsibility to implement a program to improve federal permitting coordination. The RECOs in coordination with the BLM and U.S. Forest Service (USFS) will lead the agencies in implementing the interagency coordination and expedited reviews for the lands the agencies administer. The MOU sets forth each of the signatory agencies’ roles and responsibilities in reviews of renewable projects, including providing the RECOs with an agency point of contact for coordination.

    This initiative aims to 1) increase coordination of environmental and other agencies reviews, 2) improve interagency cooperation in the National and BLM RECOs, 3) identify opportunities to work with state and Tribal governments (including those without Renewable Energy Portfolio Standards), and 4) streamline the project approval process by eliminating duplication and building consistency with the goal of accelerating decision making. The MOU states specifically that the agencies will “prioritize and expedite” the approval process with the goal of authorizing at least 25 gigawatts of renewable energy on federal lands administered by DOI and USDA by December 31, 2025. Further, the MOU anticipates that continued cooperation among the agencies will result in additional authorization of renewable projects on federal lands between 2025-2030. The MOU also notes that the goals of improved permit coordination and expedited permitting decisions under the MOU apply to relevant aspects of agency coordination related to supporting activities including land use planning, electric transmission, energy storage (e.g., battery storage and pumped energy) research and development of new technologies and any other associated agency responsibilities and activities promoting onshore renewable energy goals.

    The MOU stipulates that, in the course of conducting the reviews, consideration will be given to “the protection for cultural resources and sacred sites as well as the Nation’s land, water, and biodiversity, and fostering creation of jobs to support local communities.” In addition, evaluation of renewable projects will be consistent with the principles and policies regarding environmental justice to underserved communities as a commitment to strong protection from environmental and health hazards for all Americans.

    While this initiative is subject to the availability of appropriated funds and budget priorities within each of the agencies in accordance with the Energy Act of 2020, the ambitious goals set forth in the MOU highlight the current administration’s focus on addressing climate change and the energy transition while supporting economic development and energy justice. The prioritization of the development of wind, solar, and geothermal facilities on federal lands presents exciting opportunities for renewable energy stakeholders and potential investors.

    [1] 43 U.S.C. § § 3001-3005, Pub. L. No. 116-260 (December 27, 2020).

    Nerdy Mind

    February 4, 2022
    Articles, Legal Alerts
  • Davis Graham Legal Alert: Dissolution of the Stay of the Vaccination & Testing Emergency Temporary Standard

    On December 17, the Fifth Circuit’s stay of the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) COVID-19 rule for employers with 100 or more employees was dissolved. While it is likely there will be petitions for the Sixth Circuit to rehear the case en banc, and there have been appeals filed in the U.S. Supreme Court, there is no stay currently in place.

    OSHA had previously announced that it would “stand down” during the Fifth Circuit’s stay. The rule’s December 5th deadline to put a written vaccination or “mask and test” policy in place has already passed. The December 17th announcement read:

    OSHA is gratified the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit dissolved the Fifth Circuit’s stay of the Vaccination and Testing Emergency Temporary Standard. OSHA can now once again implement this vital workplace health standard, which will protect the health of workers by mitigating the spread of the unprecedented virus in the workplace.

    To account for any uncertainty created by the stay, OSHA is exercising enforcement discretion with respect to the compliance dates of the Emergency Temporary Standard (ETS). To provide employers with sufficient time to come into compliance, OSHA will not issue citations for noncompliance with any requirements of the ETS before January 10 and will not issue citations for noncompliance with the standard’s testing requirements before February 9, so long as an employer is exercising reasonable, good faith efforts to come into compliance with the standard. OSHA will work closely with the regulated community to provide compliance assistance.

    OSHA is currently intending to enforce this standard commencing on January 10, 2022, barring another stay. In order to be in compliance with the standard on January 10th, some work toward developing a written policy will be needed to move forward.

    Please contact Laura Riese or a Davis Graham Partner if you have any questions or if we can assist you with any legal needs.

    Nerdy Mind

    December 20, 2021
    Legal Alerts
Previous Page
1 … 14 15 16 17 18 … 33
Next Page
3400 Walnut Street, Suite 700, Denver, CO  80205
303.892.9400
Stay Connected

Sign up to receive our newsletter or update your preferences.

© 2026 Davis Graham

  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookie Policy
Manage Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
  • Manage options
  • Manage services
  • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
  • Read more about these purposes
View preferences
  • {title}
  • {title}
  • {title}