Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS)—often called “forever chemicals”—have dominated environmental law headlines in recent years. Most recently, the DC Circuit upheld EPA’s designation of two PFAS compounds (PFOA and PFOS) as hazardous substances under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA). Mining and metals companies face PFAS-related liability risks given the historical and ongoing uses of PFAS-containing materials in these industries—from firefighting foams to ore processing and metal finishing. These risks include legacy contamination that may give rise to CERCLA litigation and enforcement, as well as potential ongoing compliance obligations, including Toxics Release Inventory (TRI) reporting under the Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act (EPCRA) and discharge permitting under the Clean Water Act (CWA). Companies should consult with counsel to evaluate potential exposure from both ongoing operations and legacy activities.
I. Background on PFAS and Evolving Regulations
PFAS are a class of thousands of synthetic chemicals characterized by strong carbon-fluorine bonds, making them resistant to heat, water, and oil. Since their development in the 1940s and 1950s, PFAS have been used extensively in fire suppressant foams (AFFF), surfactants, and other industrial applications. The chemical properties that make PFAS useful also make them extraordinarily persistent in the environment—they do not break down under normal conditions and can migrate through soil into groundwater. Research has linked certain PFAS to adverse health effects, including reproductive issues and increased cancer risk, driving heightened regulatory scrutiny.
The regulatory landscape for PFAS continues to evolve. Key regulations have been promulgated under the Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA), the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA), and EPCRA. Most significantly for the mining sector, in April 2024, EPA designated PFOA and PFOS as “hazardous substances” under CERCLA Section 102(a)—the first time EPA has exercised this rulemaking authority. The designation requires reporting of releases that meet or exceed one pound within a 24-hour period, authorizes EPA enforcement actions, and exposes potentially responsible parties to strict, joint and several liability.
In a challenge by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and other industry groups, the DC Circuit recently upheld EPA’s rule, affirming the agency’s authority to designate PFOA and PFOS as hazardous substances under CERCLA (Chamber of Com. of the U.S. v. EPA, 187 F.4th 636 (D.C. Cir. 2026)). The decision removes a key source of regulatory uncertainty and confirms that PFOA and PFOS contamination will remain subject to CERCLA’s federal enforcement and liability framework.
II. PFAS Use in Mining and Metals
PFAS litigation has proliferated in recent years, primarily targeting manufacturers and sites with known AFFF use. Mining and metals operations have received limited attention. However, PFAS liability risks nonetheless may arise due to AFFF usage at mine sites and industry-specific applications in ore processing and metal finishing. Key activities and sources may include:
- AFFF firefighting foam: PFAS-containing aqueous film-forming foam has been used at mine sites to combat fires in remote locations and high-hazard settings. For example, at the Sugar Camp Mine in Illinois, AFFF deployment to combat an underground fire resulted in PFOS concentrations in nearby surface waters exceeding 50 times the federal drinking water standard, leading to enforcement and private litigation.
- Leaching and flotation: PFAS-based surfactants have been used in copper and gold extraction operations to enhance wetting and improve metal recovery.
- Mist suppression and metal finishing: PFAS have been used as mist suppressants in copper electrowinning and as wetting agents in chrome plating, electroplating, and anodizing operations.
- Equipment and materials: Fluoropolymers are used in some equipment components, including pipes, cables, hoses, and conveyor belts. PFAS-based surfactants may also be present in drilling fluids, paints, coatings, and cleaners used in mining operations, although these products do not necessarily contain PFOA or PFOS.
- Biosolids: Biosolids (treated sewage sludge) have been used to improve revegetation and reclamation at legacy mining sites but often contain PFAS. The Palmerton Zinc Pile Superfund site illustrates this risk—biosolids applied in the 1990s for revegetation are recognized as a likely source of PFAS contamination in the municipal drinking water supply. Maine has prohibited land application of biosolids, and other states, like Connecticut, have enacted similar laws.
III. Compliance, Enforcement, and Litigation Risks
As noted, PFAS-related liability risks for mining and metals companies may include both legacy contamination concerns (e.g., under CERCLA) and ongoing compliance requirements (e.g., CWA permitting, TRI reporting and waste management). Key regulatory frameworks are summarized below.
CERCLA: Following the 2024 designation of PFOA and PFOS as hazardous substances—now upheld by the DC Circuit—facilities must report releases that meet or exceed one pound within a 24-hour period. Civil actions by governmental and private parties to address PFOA and PFOS contamination are becoming more common. In an April 2024 memo, EPA indicated it will focus enforcement on “significant contributors,” which may include mining and metals operations in some circumstances. EPA has begun investigating the possible presence of PFAS in mine site cleanups.
EPCRA and TSCA: Over 200 PFAS are now TRI-reportable with a 100-pound threshold—significantly below standard TRI thresholds. EPA has designated PFAS as “chemicals of special concern,” so PFAS in low concentrations in mixtures and trade-name products must be counted toward thresholds. TRI reporting can apply to ancillary use of PFAS-containing products. Additionally, companies that have imported PFAS-containing equipment could face reporting obligations under Section 8(a)(7) of TSCA, although EPA has proposed a rule that would implement broad exemptions and reduce exposure for importers and products with only small amounts of PFAS.
CWA: EPA has signaled it may pursue PFAS-related effluent limitation guidelines (including for metal finishing and electroplating wastewater discharges that may contain PFAS). State action is also likely, and PFAS-related permit terms are emerging. Citizen suits under the CWA have already targeted PFAS contamination from biosolids application, resulting in consent decrees requiring remedial actions (for example, this decree in CRBI v. City of Calhoun, No. 4:24-cv-68 (N.D. Ga. Aug. 8, 2024)).
SDWA: Remote mine sites that operate water systems serving 25 or more people may be subject to SDWA requirements. Initial monitoring for PFOA and PFOS must be completed by April 2027, and compliance with the Maximum Contaminant Levels (MCLs) of 4.0 ppt is required by 2029. EPA has proposed extending certain deadlines and rescinding some MCLs (for PFHxS, PFNA, HFPO-DA, and the hazard index), but the 2024 rule remains in effect.
State laws and other exposure: Many states have enacted PFAS drinking water standards, restrictions on PFAS in products and packaging, biosolids application prohibitions, and state superfund or cleanup programs targeting PFAS contamination. Some states have also banned the manufacture, distribution, sale, and/or use of firefighting foams with intentionally added PFAS. Additionally, common-law toxic tort suits against potential sources of PFAS contamination have proliferated.
IV. Next Steps
Given the expanding web of PFAS regulations, mining and metals companies should identify and evaluate their PFAS-related liability risks, particularly related to PFOA and PFOS. There is no one-size-fits-all approach. However, mandatory reporting requirements (under CERCLA and potentially EPCRA and TSCA) and monitoring requirements (under the SDWA) make at least some level of compliance assessment prudent.
Potential action items include the following:
- Assess current and historical operations – Evaluate whether PFAS are currently used or were historically used in operations, such as in AFFF for firefighting, ore processing surfactants, fluoropolymer equipment components, and biosolids used for reclamation. Where feasible, explore opportunities to reduce or eliminate PFAS use through substitution or process changes.
- Review insurance coverage – Review current policies for PFAS exclusions and assess whether legacy policies may cover claims arising now.
- Preserve institutional knowledge – Identify employees, retirees, or contractors with knowledge of historical PFAS use and develop a plan to capture that information. This knowledge base can be critical to assessing liability and constructing a defensible factual record.
- Establish compliance protocols – Develop internal protocols for evaluating PFAS in new materials, tracking regulatory updates, and ensuring adherence to current and future regulatory requirements.
- Evaluate disclosure obligations – Public companies should assess whether PFAS-related exposure warrants disclosure in financial filings. All companies should consider how potential PFAS liabilities may affect lending relationships and project financing.
- Address transactional considerations – PFAS considerations are increasingly relevant in property and asset transactions. Buyers and sellers should consult with environmental counsel on how best to evaluate and address PFAS in the transactional context. Companies may consider updating due diligence protocols, including Phase I environmental site assessment practices, to include PFAS-specific evaluations as warranted by the context.
Davis Graham has extensive experience with the transactional, operational, and environmental questions and challenges facing mining and metals companies. For questions about this legal alert, please contact a member of the Energy & Mining Group or Environmental & Public Lands Group.